Frequently Asked Questions

Email Support

Still got questions? Shoot us an email!


Processing Time: Typically 1-2 weeks, often sooner. This is the time we take to make and fulfill your order in our apartment.

USPS Shipping Speed:

  • US Orders: 2-5 business days.
  • International Orders: 1-4 weeks.

Please Note: These are just estimates. Occasionally, delays can happen due to factors beyond our control.

Tracking Your Order: Once your order is packed and ready, we'll send you a tracking number via email. It may take about 12 hours for the tracking information to update in the system.

If you need to change or cancel your order, please contact us within one hour of placing it. We’ll try our best to accommodate your request. However, once your package is with USPS, modifications may not be possible.

We encourage you to review your order carefully before purchasing to ensure everything is as you desire.

If you realize that your shipping address is incorrect, please email us as soon as possible. We’ll do our best to update it before your order is shipped. However, if your order has already been dispatched to USPS, you’ll need to contact them directly for further assistance.

  • Important: Your package will be sent to the exact address you provide. That’s why it’s crucial to double-check your address when placing an order. If a package is returned to us due to an incorrect address you've entered, you will be responsible for the re-ship cost. Regrettably, we cannot offer refunds or replacements for items shipped to an incorrect address.

In case your package is marked 'Delivered' but you haven't received it, start by checking around your delivery area and confirming the shipping address you provided. Sometimes, packages can be marked as 'delivered' before they actually arrive. If you still can't find your package after 3 days, we recommend contacting USPS to file a claim.

While we strive to ensure every order reaches its destination, please understand that Overthinker Apparel cannot be held responsible for lost or stolen packages once they leave our facility.

If your package is showing as "in transit" for an extended period, please contact USPS at 1-800-275-8777 for the latest status update. They can provide insights into any ongoing delays.

Although Overthinker Apparel is ready to assist where we can, please be aware that we cannot control delays once the package is with USPS.

Returns & Exchanges

Absolutely! We want you to be completely satisfied with your Overthinker Apparel purchase. If you've had a change of heart, here's what to do:

  • Condition for Return: Your item must be in its original condition - unworn, unwashed, with all tags attached, and free of any signs of wear such as makeup, deodorant stains, perfumes, pet hair, or cigarette smell.

Return Process:

Step 1: Initiate your return through our return portal. 

  • Click here for step by step instructions.

Step 2: Prepare the item for return and include the packing slip for quicker processing.

Step 3: Select Your Preferred Shipping Option for Returns

  • You can: Purchase a shipping label at your local post office.
  • Prefer a Free Return? Choose a refund as store credit and we'll take care of the return shipping cost for you.

Step 4: Drop off your package at the post office within 15 days of receiving your order.

Please Note:

  • All returns are subject to an inspection. We reserve the right to refuse returns that don’t meet our standards.
  • Click here for Non-Returnable Items
  • We are not responsible for items not purchased from Overthinker Apparel but mistakenly returned to us.

We have a few exceptions to our return policy:

  • Final Sale Items: Items from our Greeting Cards, Slippers, Glass Cans, Ceramic Mugs, Cup Accessories, Overstock Sale, Oopsie Sale, and all gift cards are considered final sale and are not eligible for return or exchange.
  • Special Promotions: Items bought during special promotional events are eligible for returns, but only for store credit.

We currently don't offer direct exchanges. However, you have the option to return an item for a refund and then place a new order for the item you're interested in. This way, you can get exactly what you want without the wait. 

  • Click here for return instructions.

At Overthinker Apparel, we take great care in processing your orders, but sometimes mistakes can happen. If you encounter any issues, such as receiving a damaged or incorrect item, please contact us within 72 hours of receiving your order, along with pictures of the issue. We're committed to making things right, either by providing a replacement or offering a refund, which can be issued as store credit or back to your original payment method, depending on your preference.

Please Note: Differences in color due to screen settings or lighting conditions are not considered as damage.

To start a return, first, click the profile icon in our store's navigation or go to our refund policy or returns page. Then, follow these steps to request a return:

Step 1: Log in to Your Account:

  • Enter your email address in the Email field and click Continue.
  • Open the email from our store in your email account and copy the six-digit verification code.
  • Return to the online store and enter the six-digit verification code.

Step 2: Select Your Order: Click on the order you wish to return.
Step 3: Choose Items to Return: If your order has multiple items, select the ones you want to return.
Step 4: Select a Return Reason: Choose a reason for the return and add any additional notes for the store.
Step 5: Request the Return: Click on 'Request return'.

If your return request is approved and requires shipping, you’ll receive an email with shipping instructions and a return shipping label. Once we receive the returned product, you will be issued a refund.

Here’s how our refund process works:

  • Timing: We aim to process refunds within a week of receiving your returned item.
  • Refund Methods:
    • Original Payment Method: We can refund you through the payment method you used for the purchase.
    • Store Credit: Alternatively, we offer refunds as store credit, which will be issued to you as an e-Gift Card.
  • Non-refundable Charges: Please note that shipping fees and any handling surcharges cannot be refunded.
  • Special Promotions: Items bought during special promotions are eligible for refunds only as store credit.

Payment Issues

We understand the frustration and inconvenience caused by payment issues. Here are some steps you can take:

  • For Declined Payments: Please ensure that all your card’s billing details, including the security code and billing address, are entered correctly and match those associated with your card. Our system requires exact matches for the sake of security.

  • Handling Failed Transactions: Failed transactions usually rectify themselves within a few days. However, if the issue persists, please don't hesitate to email us. We're here to help sort it out.

ATTN: International Customers

International customers are responsible for any customs fees, taxes, or tariffs on their orders. These are set by your country and collected at delivery. For specific amounts, please check with your local customs office.

If an international package is declined at delivery or returned to Overthinker Apparel, we will issue store credit for the value of your order, minus the international shipping cost.

For customers returning items from outside the US, please be aware that you are responsible for any customs duties and fees, as well as the return shipping costs. We recommend reviewing your local customs policies to understand these potential charges before making a return.

Intellectual Property

All images, designs, and content on the website are the intellectual property of Overthinker Apparel and are protected by copyright laws. Any unauthorized use, reproduction, or distribution of our images, designs, and content is strictly prohibited and may result in legal action. Please contact us if you would like to use any of our intellectual property.

Changes to Policy

Our terms and policies are subject to change at any time. We encourage our valued customers to review these periodically to stay informed about any updates.