Skip to content

Free Shipping on U.S. orders over $100

Free Shipping on U.S. orders over $100

Featured
Clothing
Drinkware
Lifestyle
Sale

Shop All Drinkware

Shop All Drinkware
Shop All Sale – Discounted Apparel, Gifts & More

Shop All Sale – Discounted Apparel, Gifts & More

Account

Other sign in options Sign in

Orders
Profile

Account

Other sign in options Sign in

Orders
Profile

Total items in cart: 0 0

Cozy Holiday

New Arrivals

Best Sellers

E-Gift Cards

Cozy Holiday Gifts for Women | Thoughtful Christmas Sweatshirts & Accessories

Cozy Holiday Gifts for Women | Thoughtful Christmas Sweatshirts & Accessories
New Arrivals

New Arrivals

Shop All Clothing

Hoodies + Sweatshirts

Graphic Tees

Hats & Totes

Products

Products
Shop All Clothing – Hoodies, Sweatshirts, Tees & Everyday Comfort

Shop All Clothing – Hoodies, Sweatshirts, Tees & Everyday Comfort

Shop All Drinkware

Tumblers

Mugs

Coasters

Shop All Drinkware

Shop All Drinkware
Glass Tumblers

Glass Tumblers

Shop All Lifestyle

Journals & Planners

Trinket Dishes

Charms & Keychains

Bumper Stickers & Magnets

Snoopy

Miffy

Journals & Planners

Journals & Planners
Catch-Alls

Catch-Alls

Shop All Sale

Overstock Sale

Oopsie Sale

Sample Sale

Shop All Sale – Discounted Apparel, Gifts & More

Shop All Sale – Discounted Apparel, Gifts & More
Overstock Deals

Overstock Deals

Cup Accessories

Skip to results list

Availability

In stock
Out of stock

Price

$

to

$

The highest price is $26.99

Clear

9 items

Sort

Sort Featured

Featured

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Column grid

Column grid

Filter

Availability

In stock
Out of stock

Price

$

to

$

The highest price is $26.99

Sort

Sort Featured

Featured

Best selling

Alphabetically, A-Z

Alphabetically, Z-A

Price, low to high

Price, high to low

Date, old to new

Date, new to old

Tufted Heart Coaster – Handmade Plush Mug Rug & Jewelry Mat

Sale

Tufted Heart Coaster – Handmade Plush Mug Rug & Jewelry Mat

Tufted Heart Coaster – Handmade Plush Mug Rug & Jewelry Mat

Sale price $24.99 USD Regular price $27.99 USD
Coquette Bow Tufted Coaster – Handmade Mug Rug & Jewelry Mat
Sale

Coquette Bow Tufted Coaster – Handmade Mug Rug & Jewelry Mat
Coquette Bow Tufted Coaster – Handmade Mug Rug & Jewelry Mat

Sale price $25.99 USD Regular price $30.00 USD
Tufted Flower Placemat – Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor (Peach)

Sale

Tufted Flower Placemat – Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor (Peach)

Tufted Flower Placemat – Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor (Peach)

Sale price $14.99 USD Regular price $25.00 USD
Tufted Flower Placemat – Lavender Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor

Sale

Tufted Flower Placemat – Lavender Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor

Tufted Flower Placemat – Lavender Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor

Sale price $14.99 USD Regular price $25.00 USD
Tufted Flower Placemat – Pink Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Cute Desk Decor

Sale

Tufted Flower Placemat – Pink Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Cute Desk Decor

Tufted Flower Placemat – Pink Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Cute Desk Decor

Sale price $14.99 USD Regular price $25.00 USD
Tufted Flower Placemat – Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor (Blue)

Sale

Tufted Flower Placemat – Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor (Blue)

Tufted Flower Placemat – Handmade Jumbo Coaster & Desk Decor (Blue)

Sale price $14.99 USD Regular price $25.00 USD
Chunky Glass Smoothie Straw – Reusable, Handmade & Eco-Friendly

Sale

Chunky Glass Smoothie Straw – Reusable, Handmade & Eco-Friendly

Chunky Glass Smoothie Straw – Reusable, Handmade & Eco-Friendly

Sale price $15.99 USD Regular price $23.99 USD
Wavy Glass Straws – Reusable & Aesthetic

Wavy Glass Straws – Reusable & Aesthetic

Wavy Glass Straws – Reusable & Aesthetic

$6.00 USD
Wiggle Glass Straws – Fun & Sustainable Sipping

Wiggle Glass Straws – Fun & Sustainable Sipping

Wiggle Glass Straws – Fun & Sustainable Sipping

$6.00 USD

Email

Help Help

Shipping
Returns
International Orders
FAQs

About About

Our Story
Customer Support

Collab Collab

Brand Partnerships
Wholesale

© 2026 OVERTHINKER APPAREL, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service
Shipping policy
Contact information

Search

Search

Best Sellers

Life Is Better With You Embroidered Sweatshirt – Soft Everyday Crewneck

Life Is Better With You Embroidered Sweatshirt – Soft Everyday Crewneck

$59.99 USD
It’s OK to Take a Break Embroidered Sweatshirt – Lightweight Crewneck

It’s OK to Take a Break Embroidered Sweatshirt – Lightweight Crewneck

$44.99 USD
Good Things Take Time Embroidered Sweatshirt – Soft Slow-Living Crewneck

Good Things Take Time Embroidered Sweatshirt – Soft Slow-Living Crewneck

$54.99 USD
Be Gentle With Yourself Embroidered Sweatshirt – Rose Pink Crewneck

Be Gentle With Yourself Embroidered Sweatshirt – Rose Pink Crewneck

$64.99 USD